Brief filed in effort to restore Fourteenth Amendment, end birthright citizenship

Spread the love

America First Legal is leading the charge for the United States to return to the “original meaning” of the Fourteenth Amendment, meaning that children born to illegal aliens in the country are not American citizens.

“Citizenship is not automatic, nor is it a right: it is earned through allegiance, consent, and law,” a press release from nonprofit law firm America First Legal (AFL) said.

“The Framers said it plainly: the Citizenship Clause does not include ‘aliens or anyone owing allegiance to a foreign sovereignty,’” the release said. “Courts and scholars ever since have agreed.”

AFL said that it and law firm Boyden Gray PLLC “filed an amicus brief in the U.S. Supreme Court on behalf of eighteen members of the House Judiciary Committee.”

When contacted twice each, neither AFL nor Boyden Gray responded.

In their brief, the law firms urged “the Court to defend the original meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment and the limits it places on U.S. citizenship,” the release said.

The brief made the point that children born to foreign ambassadors or invading soldiers living in the United States are not considered U.S. citizens, as stated in the release.

This idea is “not because those parents have immunity, but because they owe allegiance elsewhere,” the release said.

“The same principle applies to children of aliens unlawfully present in the country: their parents owe allegiance to another nation and are here without the consent of the United States,” the release said.

“This is not a question of compassion, but of constitutional order,” the release said. “Citizenship cannot be born of defiance, and allegiance cannot exist without consent.”

Additionally, AFL’s brief “argues that allegiance is a reciprocal bond requiring loyalty from the individual and consent from the sovereign. When that consent is broken, citizenship cannot be claimed.”

The release explained that “the Fourteenth Amendment enshrines this principle, granting citizenship only to those born or naturalized in the United States and subject to its jurisdiction – meaning total, exclusive allegiance and lawful presence, not mere location.”

Only Congress can confer citizenship, the release stated.

“The Fourteenth Amendment does not confer citizenship on the children of illegal aliens, and Congress has never granted it by statute,” the release said. “Thus, it may not be conferred upon the children of aliens, regardless of birthplace.”

Vice President of America First Legal Dan Epstein said in the release: “Our history and tradition stand for the proposition that citizenship depends upon a public determination of allegiance.”

“Being subject to the country’s jurisdiction is not a default presumption. Instead, citizenship is a duty, a bond, and a privilege reserved for those who are subject to our laws and our sovereignty into an entitlement,” Epstein said.

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

WATCH: WA Senate candidates differ on taxes, parental rights, protecting girls' sports

WATCH: WA Senate candidates differ on taxes, parental rights, protecting girls’ sports

By Carleen JohnsonThe Center Square With less than two weeks before the general election, two candidates for one of the most closely watched races in Washington state are sharing their...
Newsom, Bonta vow suit over National Guard deployment

Newsom, Bonta vow suit over National Guard deployment

By Madeline ShannonThe Center Square Editor's note: This story has been updated since its initial publication. Gov. Gavin Newsom addressed concerns that President Donald Trump is sending federal agents to...
U.S. nuclear stockpile hit with shutdown furloughs

U.S. nuclear stockpile hit with shutdown furloughs

By Liam HibbertThe Center Square All 68 federal employees at a Nevada nuclear stockpile site were furloughed in the wake of the U.S. government shutdown. Some contractors remain at the...
Spokane police chief ordered officers not to work with FBI after June 11 protest

Spokane police chief ordered officers not to work with FBI after June 11 protest

By Tim ClouserThe Center Square Spokane Police Chief Kevin Hall directed officers not to work with the FBI in the days following the June 11 immigration protests, according to records...
Treasury sanctions Russian oil companies, calls for ceasefire

Treasury sanctions Russian oil companies, calls for ceasefire

By Andrew RiceThe Center Square The U.S. Treasury Department announced sanctions against two Russian oil companies on Wednesday. The department cited Russia's "lack of serious commitment" to ending the war...
DOJ: Illegal immigrant charged with assault

DOJ: Illegal immigrant charged with assault

By Dave MasonThe Center Square An illegal immigrant from Mexico was expected to make his first court appearance Wednesday following an arrest in which he rammed law enforcement vehicles before...
Manufacturing advocate: 'Follow the actions' with Pritzker on taxes

Manufacturing advocate: ‘Follow the actions’ with Pritzker on taxes

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Gov. J.B. Pritzker says he prefers growing the economy over raising taxes, but a small and midsize...
Illinois quick hits: National Guard restraining order extended; economic growth above trend

Illinois quick hits: National Guard restraining order extended; economic growth above trend

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square National Guard restraining order extended Following an agreement between the state of Illinois and the federal government, U.S. District Court Judge...
US and Qatar say EU climate regulations could impact LNG supplies

US and Qatar say EU climate regulations could impact LNG supplies

By Alton WallaceThe Center Square The U.S. Department of Energy is urging the heads of State in the European Union (EU) to repeal or significantly change climate regulations adopted in...
U.S. debt tops $38 trillion for first time

U.S. debt tops $38 trillion for first time

By Brett RowlandThe Center Square The U.S. national debt reached $38 trillion amid a partial federal government that costs taxpayers $400 million daily to pay furloughed federal workers to stay...
Trump defends tariffs, tells beef producers to lower prices

Trump defends tariffs, tells beef producers to lower prices

By Brett RowlandThe Center Square Cattle producers called on President Donald Trump to reverse course on a plan to import beef from Argentina as prices for the grocery store staple...
VA secretary pleads with Democrats to end the shutdown

VA secretary pleads with Democrats to end the shutdown

By Morgan SweeneyThe Center Square As part of a visit to the Washington, D.C., veterans’ medical center Wednesday, Department of Veterans Affairs Secretary Doug Collins publicly urged Democrats in Congress...

WATCH: Pritzker opposes redistricting Illinois mid-cycle as other states move forward

By Greg Bishop | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – The prospect of Illinois legislators changing the state’s congressional maps before the 2026 election seems unlikely with...
Record-long govt shutdown threatens food, early childhood education assistance

Record-long govt shutdown threatens food, early childhood education assistance

By Thérèse BoudreauxThe Center Square Senate Democrats are set to block Republicans’ government funding bill for the 12th time Wednesday, keeping the federal government shut down despite tens of millions...
Sen. Scott Wiener announces he's running for Pelosi's seat

Sen. Scott Wiener announces he’s running for Pelosi’s seat

By Dave MasonThe Center Square State Sen. Scott Wiener, a San Francisco Democrat and vocal opponent of the Trump administration, announced Wednesday he’s running for U.S. Rep. Nancy Pelosi’s seat....