Multiple briefs filed with Texas Supreme Court in Abbott lawsuit against Wu

Multiple briefs filed with Texas Supreme Court in Abbott lawsuit against Wu

Multiple individuals have filed amicus briefs with the Texas Supreme Court in response to an emergency writ of quo warranto petition filed by Texas Gov. Greg Abbott to have state Rep. Gene Wu, D-Houston, removed from office.

Abbott filed the petition on Wednesday after more than 50 House Democrats fled the state to prevent a vote on Congressional redistricting. The court established its first deadline for Friday, when individuals filed briefs with the court in support of Abbott or Wu.

U.S. Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, filed a brief in support of Abbott saying, “Under this Court’s precedent, an original writ of quo warranto to the Texas Supreme Court is an appropriate remedy, and Governor Abbott is a proper petitioner.”

Abbott and Cornyn are both former Texas Supreme Court justices. Contrary to a brief filed by the Texas Solicitor General, Cornyn argues, “There is no conflict with Chapter 66 of the Texas Civil Practice as Governor Abbott is seeking relief under separate constitutional authority” and “Governor Abbott is a proper petitioner.”

“These types of proceedings may be initiated by persons other than the Texas Attorney General. If even a private person can bring a writ of quo warranto, then Governor Abbott acting in his official capacity is surely a proper petitioner,” Cornyn said.

Cornyn also highlights issues with filings by Attorney General Ken Paxton, arguing his petition to remove 13 Democrats “duplicated the Governor’s petition in this Court – in some instances word for word – but then sought an individualized writ on behalf of a purported class of respondents. Surprisingly, the Attorney General again invites delay by suggesting this Court should give absconded Democrats more time – ’48 hours’ after issuance of any decision – to consider their options. The Texas legislators who have absconded to other states must be held accountable and a quorum restored so that official government business can proceed.”

He asks the court to support Abbott’s request.

State Democratic representatives from El Paso, Joe Moody and Mary Gonzalez, filed an amicus brief in support of Wu. Moody serves as the House Speaker Pro Tempore, a position he’s held under three speakers. “Texas legislators have many duties besides voting on bills. Their oath states that they must ‘preserve, protect, and defend the Constitution and laws of the United States and of this State,’” they argue.

They also argue Wu is “at work right now. His constituents have asked him to fulfill his oath to protect their rights by breaking quorum, and he has followed in the footsteps of many past legislators from both parties in doing so. It’s little different than walking up to the back microphone on the House floor and raising a point of order in hopes of defeating a bill without a vote. Simply put, Wu is still doing his job.”

Accepting donations to cover travel expenses isn’t bribery, they argue, and “There’s no evidence of any quid pro quo because the decision to break quorum preceded any solicitation of funds.”

“So much in our politics seems to be about power for its own sake, whatever the cost. That cost may finally be too high today. This Court should refuse to pay it,” they argue.

Harris County Attorney Christian Menefee also filed a brief in support of Wu. In it, he argues Abbott “has usurped the authority of other elected officials to bring quo warranto proceedings, and that his reliance on common law authority to do so is belied by case law and statute.” The brief also explains that even if abandonment of office were grounds for quo warranto removal, Abbott’s petition does not clarify how Wu “abandoned his office in any legally relevant way.”

Menefee also argues, ‘if a brief absence with a clear end date causes a legislator to abandon their office under the Texas Constitution, legislators could never leave their districts for any reason, including traveling to Austin for any special or regular session.”

Wu, among 33 Democrats sued by the Texas House, remains in Illinois. He said on Friday, “This fight is so much bigger than me, our district, or even Texas. It’s about protecting our democracy.”

House Speaker Dustin Burrows on Friday said, “all hands were on deck” to arrest and return missing Democrats. The House is five members short of meeting quorum to conduct official business. Legislation, and relief funds to help Hill Country victims, have stalled because of Democrats halting House proceedings.

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

Screenshot 2025-07-09 at 10.53.38 AM

Council Increases Popcorn Festival Funding to $25,000 After Heated Budget Debate

Casey City Council approved a $25,000 donation to the annual Popcorn Festival Monday night after a lengthy and sometimes tense discussion about the city's financial priorities and the festival's growing...
Screenshot 2025-07-09 at 10.53.13 AM

Casey Moves Forward with Hotel Feasibility Study and TIF District Analysis

Casey City Council approved two economic development initiatives Monday night aimed at increasing tourism revenue and expanding development opportunities in the community. Council members unanimously approved a hotel feasibility study...
Meeting Briefs

Casey City Council July 7 Meeting Briefs

Police Vehicle Purchase: Casey City Council approved the purchase of a 2025 Chevrolet Tahoe squad car for $54,864 from Mike Chevrolet. The vehicle was budgeted in last year's appropriations but...
Donna-Wilson

Donna K. Wilson

Donna K. Wilson, age 82, of Martinsville, IL, passed away peacefully at 7:40 a.m. on Thursday, July 3, 2025, at Casey Health Care Center, Casey, IL. She was born on...
cooling

Cooling Centers Available

When temperatures exceed 90°F, individuals beyond the senior demographic face potential risks if their cooling mechanisms malfunction. The Township, Senior Center, and Emergency Management Agency (E.M.A.) offer a cooling center...
no carts

No Carts in Fairview Park Walking Paths

The Casey Police Department wants to remind residents that no golf carts, ATVs, or motorized vehicles of any kind are allowed on the walking and biking path in Fairview Park,...
Rocking Chair.2

Beauty around the Rocking Chair

The Rocking Chair was looking beautiful for visitors this Fourth of July weekend.
The Marketing Team of Downstate Illinois was present at Tuesday’s Rotary Club weekly meeting at Richards Farm. They were the guests of new member Tom Daughhetee, Economic Development Director for the City of Casey. Pictured (l to right) are Christine Orr, Sales & Marketing Director; Abbie Hernandez, Sales & Marketing Specialist; Jordan Jackovich, Communications Manager; and Daughhetee. Photo by Sharon Durham

Rotary Hosts Discover Downstate Illinois Marketing Team

Discover Downstate Illinois Marketing Team takes care of everything from the planning, designing, placing, and even paying some of the bills for members. They can assist with various marketing projects,...
Julie-Redman-1751715715

Julie Beth Redman

Julie Beth (Hughes) Redman, age 60, of Casey, IL, passed away at 11:44 p.m. on Sunday, June 29, 2025, at Sarah Bush Lincoln Health Center, Mattoon, IL. She was born...
Casey County Club

Julie Snyder Named Honorary Chairperson for 75th Casey Open

July at the Casey Country Club means that it is time for the Casey Open. This year, we will be celebrating the 75th year of this competitive event. Julie Snyder...
David-Hawkins-1750879480

David Eugene Hawkins

David Eugene Hawkins, age 33, of Casey, IL, passed away at 1:27 a.m. on Tuesday, June 24, 2025, in Casey, IL. He was born on March 6, 1992, in Terre...
CIA Casey in Action

Registration open now: ‘Pop On In’ to the 2025 CIA 5K Fun Run/Walk

Registration is open for Casey In Action’s annual KZ5K set for 7 a.m. Saturday, Aug. 30 with a larger than life route through downtown Casey featuring Big Things, including most...
Donald-Maxey-1750352075

Donald Lee “Don” Maxey

Donald Lee “Don” Maxey, age 61, of Martinsville, IL, passed away at 1:51 a.m. on Wednesday, June 18, 2025, at his residence. He was born December 1, 1963, in Terre...
Keith-Wattleworth-1750430743

Keith Richard Wattleworth

Keith Richard Wattleworth, a lifelong farmer and resident of Yale, Illinois, passed away peacefully at his home of 56 years on June 18, 2025. He was 90 years old. Keith...
The Casey Rotary Club celebrated its 100th Anniversary on June 17, 2025, during the weekly meeting at Richards Farm. District Governor Mike Martin of Mattoon joined the group to present a certificate to President Marcy Mumford. The actual Charter Anniversary date was January 26, 1925. Present at Tuesday’s luncheon were (front, l to r) Marcy Mumford, Shane Todd, Sharon Durham, Joyce Shore, Megan Peavler, and Brian Hancock; (back) Chris Overbeck, Wendy Navel, Kurt Squires, Jay Markwell, Mike Martin, Gary Shore, and Aaron Stinson. Not present were Christopher Snedeker and John Murphy. —photo by Chuck Ayres.

Casey Rotary Club celebrated its 100th Anniversary

The Casey Rotary Club celebrated its 100th Anniversary on June 17, 2025, during the weekly meeting at Richards Farm. District Governor Mike Martin of Mattoon joined the group to present...