States challenge federal report promoting coal plants

States challenge federal report promoting coal plants

Michigan has joined a coalition of states challenging a Department of Energy report claiming the U.S. will face a significantly increased risk of power outages by 2030.

The report argues that coal and natural gas-powered plants must remain in operation to mitigate the risk. Michigan and nine other attorneys general are pushing back.

“This report is based on flawed assumptions, overstates risks, and attempts to override the authority of states and regional regulators all to appease President Trump,” said Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel. “We cannot allow the federal government to use a manufactured emergency to prop up outdated coal plants at the expense of Michigan families and our energy future.”

The July report from the DOE argued the U.S. will face a significantly increased risk of power outages by 2030 if scheduled coal and natural gas plant retirements are allowed to proceed. The report fulfills a direction by President Donald Trump in an April executive order to “develop a uniform methodology for analyzing current and anticipated reserve margins for all regions of the bulk power system.”

The report outlined concerning results, including findings that the continued closure of plants increases the risk of power outages by 100 times in 2030.

“Our nation possesses abundant energy resources and capabilities such as oil and gas, coal, and nuclear,” the report said.

It applauded deregulation and permitting reform by the Trump administration, but argued that won’t be enough if plants continue to close.

“However, even with these foundational strengths, the accelerated retirement of existing generation capacity…undermine this energy outlook,” it said. “Absent decisive intervention, the nation’s power grid will be unable to meet projected demand for manufacturing, re-industrialization, and data centers driving artificial intelligence (AI) innovation.”

In conclusion, the report recommends keeping these plants running to maintain grid reliability. Nessel and the other attorneys general filed a request for rehearing the the DOE, arguing that the report should not be used as the basis to renew emergency orders under the Federal Power allowing for the continued operation of coal-powered plants.

“The report is deeply flawed and, if DOE is taken at its word, it will inflict significant harm on our states,” the request stated, arguing that the closure of coal plants should continue. “These retirements have been thoroughly vetted by state and regional authorities and approved only following an extensive examination of cost considerations and reliability impacts.”

It goes on to argue that the DOE is overstepping its authority and is working off of “flawed assumptions.”

Nessel was joined by the attorneys general of Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Illinois, Maryland, Minnesota, New York, and Washington in filing the rehearing request.

Michigan, Colorado, and Washington all have plants that could be affected by the findings.

In Michigan, Nessel is currently challenging a recent emergency order from the U.S. Secretary of Energy Chris Wright directing the Midcontinent Independent System Operator, in combination with Consumers Energy, to keep the J.H. Campbell coal-fired plant open in West Olive.

While the plant was scheduled to close in May, Wright ordered a 90-day stay to that decision, as previously reported by The Center Square.

“Today’s emergency order ensures that Michiganders and the greater Midwest region do not lose critical power generation capability as summer begins and electricity demand regularly reach high levels,” Wright said at the time. “This administration will not sit back and allow dangerous energy subtraction policies threaten the resiliency of our grid and raise electricity prices on American families.”

Nessel’s lawsuit is pushing for the plant to be closed immediately, arguing the emergency order was unlawful and that the plant’s continued operation could put “enormous costs onto utility customers who receive no real benefit.”

Under the Federal Power Act, the DOE has 30 days to respond to the coalition’s request for rehearing.

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

Casey Council Meeting.2

Casey Approves Utility Rate Increases, Joins Regional Land Bank Authority

Casey residents will see increases in water, sewer and electric rates following Monday's City Council meeting, as the city works to address ongoing budget challenges in its utility departments. The...
Casey Council Meeting.1

Casey Council Considers Hotel Feasibility Study to Attract Development

Casey may commission a $15,000 hotel market feasibility study as the city explores bringing new lodging options to the community. Economic Development Director Tom Daughhetee presented the proposal to the...
City Council Meeting Briefs.Purple

Casey City Council Meeting Briefs

Freedom Fest Planning Underway: Casey's Freedom Fest is scheduled for July 4-5 with events in Fairview Park. Friday's schedule includes an antique tractor pull at 10 a.m. and Saturday features...
City Council Part 1

City Council Meeting Video Part 1

https://youtu.be/bWEJPtq8Qh0?si=YzFeP3sk_tT3x111
City Council Part 2

City Council Meeting Video Part 2

https://youtu.be/6X23vHI3_D4?si=dXRZcsNn0oGW6wWN
Casey Westfield Warriors.3

Casey-Westfield Dominates Dakota 10-0 Behind Goble’s Complete Game Shutout

Casey-Westfield bounced back from a heartbreaking semifinal loss with a dominant 10-0 third-place victory over Dakota June 7th, ending their exceptional season on a high note behind Ava Goble's complete...

About Casey Local

Community-Focused & Engaging About Casey Local: Keeping Casey Informed, Connected & Collaborative! Hello, Casey! Casey Local is your dedicated local news and information source, built to bring our community closer together...

About Us!

About Casey's Big Things: Your Pocket Guide to Casey! Welcome to Casey, Illinois, the small town with BIG surprises! We created Casey's Big Things to be your ultimate companion as you explore...
Casey Council Meeting.2

Casey Approves Major Park Recreation Project, Hires Firm to Find New Utilities Chief

The Casey City Council unanimously approved a comprehensive park recreation project costing up to $339,041.78 at Monday's meeting, moving forward with improvements that will enhance the city's recreational facilities. City...
Casey Council Meeting.1

Casey in Action Secures $40,000 Grant for Park Walking Path

Casey in Action received a $40,000 grant from the Lumpkin Foundation to support the second phase of a walking path project in the city park, representatives told the City Council...
City Council Meeting Briefs.Blue

Casey Council Briefs

Economic Development Initiatives: The Economic Development Committee met May 8 to discuss several initiatives including a Tourism Director position, Freedom Fest planning, a Business District Grant program, and participation in...
Casey Westfield Warriors.2

Warriors Advance to Face Red Devils on 14-Game Win Streak

The Casey-Westfield Warriors will face the Sesser-Valier/Waltonville Red Devils at 4:30 p.m. Monday, riding a 14-game winning streak into the playoff matchup. Casey-Westfield advanced with a 1-0 shutout victory over...
Casey Council Meeting.2

Casey City Council Awards Sidewalk Contract, Approves Utility Rate Increases

The Casey City Council unanimously approved awarding a $62,502 sidewalk construction contract to Wallace Concrete at Monday's meeting, accepting the low bid from among several proposals reviewed by city staff....
Casey Council Meeting.1

Utilities Chief Announces December Retirement; Police Department Adds Officer

Casey Utility Superintendent Shelby Biggs announced at Monday's city council meeting that he will retire on December 31, 2025, ending his tenure overseeing the city's water, sewer, and electric operations....
City Council Meeting Briefs.Purple

Casey Council Meeting Briefs

July 4th Planning Begins: City Clerk Jeremy Mumford reminded the council that planning for the 4th of July celebration needs to begin soon. Mayor Mike Nichols asked the Downtown Improvement/Festivals...