'Liberation Day' reignites D.C. statehood debate

‘Liberation Day’ reignites D.C. statehood debate

As the National Guard begins patrolling the streets of Washington, D.C., after President Donald Trump announced their deployment in support of making the city safer, the move has reignited a debate over the district’s statehood.

Since the president’s Monday announcement, protests have emerged to “keep D.C. free,” after fears Congress could rescind the district’s Home Rule Act, granting it limited autonomy.

In response to Trump’s executive action to declare a crime emergency, or “Liberation Day,” in the district by implementing federal control over the Metropolitan Police Department and deploying the National Guard to patrol, Mayor Muriel Bowser is leading a call to grant the city statehood.

“It’s times like these when America needs to know why your nation’s capital, a place where 700,000 taxpaying Americans live should be the 51st state,” Bowser said on The Breakfast Club.

Trump responded while touring the Kennedy Center on Wednesday, calling the push for statehood by Democrats a power play.

“Statehood is ridiculous. We want to straighten the place out. Statehood is ridiculous. It’s unacceptable. It’s the Democrats that want it, because the Democrats have, you know, about 95% in this little area,” Trump told reporters. “They want to pick up two senators. And it’s not going to happen … And that’s the least of the reasons why … What we want to do is make Washington, D.C. the greatest, most beautiful, safest capital anywhere in the world, and that’s going to happen.”

However, Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, who introduced legislation in February to end the D.C. Home Rule Act, has suggested an alternate plan that could be a political compromise.

Lee proposed the idea of returning much of the land the district occupies to Maryland.

“If the residents of DC want to be part of a state, the solution is *not* DC statehood. Any solution should involve reverting land ceded by Maryland for the creation of DC – excepting only a narrow corridor encompassing the White House, Capitol, & Supreme Court – to Maryland,” Lee posted on X.

He noted historical context and precedence to his proposal, adding that when D.C. was established by Congress in 1790, land was ceded from Maryland and Virginia, creating a diamond-shaped district. In 1846, Congress passed legislation to retrocede the Virginia portion of the land back to the commonwealth, which now comprises much of Arlington and the City of Alexandria.

Lee argues that the district in itself “doesn’t meet the criteria” that has been “historically applied to statehood.”

“Although the Constitution doesn’t specify minimum population or geographic size, our states have been admitted as territories with balanced economies —agriculture, industry, and diverse resources … We have *never* admitted a state that consists of just a single, geographically compact, urban enclave — whether heavily dependent on the federal government…

“DC lacks anything close to the industries, natural resources, opportunities for growth, and amenities found in literally every other state. It’s just a city — one city — and therefore can’t be accorded the status of a sovereign state using the time-honored criteria. More importantly, the Founders quite intentionally created DC as a *neutral* federal district to serve as the seat of the U.S. government under Article I, Section 8,” Lee wrote.

He added that the land return would “give DC residents what they deserve—state-level representation.”

Two states, Vermont and Wyoming have smaller populations than D.C.

The District of Columbia Home Rule Act of 1973 was enacted by Congress and ratified by D.C. voters. The act gave the district residents limited autonomy over local affairs, allowing them to elect local leaders, including mayors and council members.

Despite gaining some control, ultimately, Congress has the authority to manage the nation’s capital, according to Article 1, Section 8, Clause 17 of the U.S. Constitution. The president also has the authority to appoint district judges.

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

City Council Meeting Briefs.Blue

CITY MEETING BRIEFS

Ordinance Changes Considered: Alderman Richardson reported a citizen inquiry about allowing chickens within city limits, with an ordinance committee meeting planned to discuss potential changes to current regulations. Emergency Sirens...
Casey Westfield School Board.2

Casey-Westfield Board Approves $4.5 Million Bond Issue with Local Banks

The Casey-Westfield School Board unanimously approved a $4.5 million bond issue for fire prevention, safety improvements, and building renovations during Monday's meeting, with financing arranged through three local banks at...
Casey Westfield School Board.3

Legislative Concerns and Athletic Policy Changes Address School Operations

Casey-Westfield school officials are monitoring state legislative developments that could affect district operations, while also adapting to new athletic association policies for private school competition. Superintendent Mike Shackelford alerted board...
Casey Westfield School Board.1

SCHOOL BOARD MEETING BRIEFS

Technology Infrastructure Critical: The 9-year-old junior/senior high server replacement was urgently needed due to memory loss, 95% capacity usage, and daily error codes threatening system failure. Local Banking Partnership: Three...
Casey Council Meeting.2

Casey Approves Historical Society Parade, Adds Employee Medical Benefits

The Casey City Council formally approved the Casey Historical Society Parade for May 10th and enhanced employee benefits by adding AirMedCare membership during Monday's meeting, while also advancing comprehensive planning...
Casey Council Meeting.1

Casey Advances Comprehensive Planning with Public Input Planned

Casey is moving forward with a comprehensive update to its long-range planning efforts, with public participation opportunities scheduled for April as the city works toward adopting a new comprehensive plan...
City Council Meeting Briefs.Purple

CITY MEETING BRIEFS

Summer Cleanup Scheduled: The annual city-wide cleanup will run June 7th through June 14th, with Utility Superintendent Biggs also announcing plans to advertise for summer help positions. Storm Response Active:...
Casey Council Meeting.1

Casey Police Face Staffing Changes as Officer Resigns, New Recruit Advances

The Casey Police Department is navigating personnel transitions after an officer submitted his resignation, while a new recruit continues progressing through the academy, Chief Adam Henderson reported during Monday's city...
Casey Council Meeting.2

Economic Development Initiatives Gain Momentum in Casey

Casey's economic development efforts are expanding with multiple new programs and partnerships designed to boost the city's growth prospects, Economic Development Director Tom Daughhetee announced during Monday's council meeting. Daughhetee...
City Council Meeting Briefs.Blue

CITY MEETING BRIEFS

Founder's Day Parade Planned: A Founder's Day Parade is being organized for May 10th following a request by Patty Richards during the public forum. A resolution authorizing the parade will...
Casey Westfield School Board.1

Casey-Westfield Board Holds Hearing on $4.5 Million Safety Bond Issue

The Casey-Westfield School Board conducted a public hearing on a proposed $4.5 million bond issue for fire prevention and safety improvements, while also approving 4% administrative salary increases and addressing...
Casey Westfield School Board.2

Casey-Westfield Students Excel in Academics and Community Service

Casey-Westfield students demonstrated exceptional achievement across academic, artistic, and community service activities, according to administrator reports presented during Monday's board meeting. Monroe Elementary students celebrated multiple milestones, including the 100th...
Casey Westfield School Board.3

SCHOOL BOARD MEETING BRIEFS

Bond Issue Under Review: The $4.5 million fire prevention and safety bond proposal remains under consideration following public hearing input about property tax concerns and district bonding capacity. State Funding...
Casey Council Meeting.2

Casey Moves Forward with Utility Rate Study as Resident Questions City Processes

The City of Casey took the next step toward addressing its utility rate issues during Monday's council meeting, while a resident raised concerns about city transparency and bidding processes. Utility...
City Council Meeting Briefs.Purple

CITY MEETING BRIEFS

Utility Rate Study Advances: Water and sewer rate study information is ready for submission to the Illinois Rural Water Association for professional review, moving the city closer to addressing identified...