Texas Supreme Court sets expedited briefing schedule in Abbott-Wu case

Spread the love

The Texas Supreme Court has set an expedited briefing schedule in a case filed by Gov. Greg Abbott to remove from office House Democratic Caucus Chair Rep. Gene Wu, D-Houston.

“Aligned parties are encouraged to consolidate their briefing to the extent practicable. The briefs should address all issues before the Court, including the import of the House of Representatives’ authority under TEX. CONST., art. III, §§ 8, 10, and 11. The petitions for writ of quo warranto remain under consideration by this Court,” the court’s instruction states.

The expedited briefing schedule allows the briefs to be filed up to midnight on the due date. The deadline for Abbott’s brief to be filed is Wednesday, August 20; Wu’s response is due Friday, August 29. Reply briefs are due Thursday, September 4.

On August 5, Abbott filed an emergency petition with the Texas Supreme Court to remove Wu from office. Wu led more than 50 House Democrats to abscond from their official duties in Austin, leave the state to deny the Texas House a quorum, and halt legislative business during a special session.

Abbott’s petition states that Wu’s “willful refusal to serve as a representative is abandonment of the office of representative.” He also argues the “principal duty of a legislator is to attend and participate in legislative sessions as required by Article III, Section 5 of the Texas Constitution. The quorum provisions further underscore that attendance is not optional; it is an affirmative constitutional obligation.”

“Representative Wu has openly renounced these constitutional mandates by fleeing the State of Texas to break quorum, obstruct legislative proceedings, and paralyze the Texas House of Representatives,” he argues, The Center Square reported.

Wu’s responded, arguing the Texas Supreme Court doesn’t have the authority to remove him from office. Only “two-thirds of the House of Representatives” has the authority to do that, he said, citing Article III, Section 11 of the Texas Constitution.

He also argues Abbott’s request is “unprecedented” and “Texas has a long history of quorumbreaking, which the Texas Constitution expressly contemplates and assigns to the legislative branch for enforcement. The petition, for the first time, asks the judiciary to remove an elected member of a co-equal branch.”

He also cites examples for why Abbott’s petition can be “denied on numerous grounds, both jurisdictional and procedural.”

Abbott also directed the Texas Rangers to investigate potential bribery charges of absconding House Democrats who have been fundraising to thwart official legislative business.

He also addresses the bribery charge in his petition requesting Wu be removed from office. It states, “Wu’s actions violate Article XVI, Section 41, which requires forfeiture of his office. … There is an especially good reason why bribery may form the basis for removal from office: Our Constitution seeks to root out bribery at practically every turn. The oath-of-office provisions, for example, obligate state officers to sign a statement swearing that they have not and will not exchange things of value ‘for the giving or withholding of a vote.’”

He asked the court to remove Wu from office to “ensure that public office remains a trust exercised in good faith, as opposed to a platform for private gain and governmental sabotage.”

In response, Wu argues Abbott’s petition makes “conclusory allegations and cites three news articles and two social media posts to support his bribery claim. … Even setting aside that these are allegations, not competent evidence, they fail to make out a case for bribery.”

“There are no facts to at all establish that Representative Wu engaged in a quid pro quo arrangement,” it continues. He also argues, “it is commonplace for elected officials to tie appeals for political contributions to specific policy actions they intend to or have taken.”

In Abbott’s response, he states, “Wu nowhere controverts the facts in the petition.”

“Wu insists he is carrying out his duties ‘as his judgment dictates.’ But with no regard for carrying out his duties in the way the Constitution requires. Our Constitution is structured to deliver a quorum, not to prevent one,” he continues.

“Wu’s determination that ‘special session is over’ grinds government to a halt, arrogating to himself the Governor’s prerogative to call a Special Session and the Speaker’s ability to gavel out, undermining the Legislature’s duty to meet and act on bills,” Abbott argues.

In response to Wu claiming the Texas Constitution enables quorum breaking, Abbott said it does so “in the same way that a highway ‘enables’ one to reach speeds of 120 mph in a 60 mph zone. Exercising the ‘freedom’ to speed may result in law enforcement issuing a speeding ticket, hauling the driver into court, and ultimately – if infractions persist – taking away the driver’s license.”

More than a dozen amicus briefs have been filed in support of Abbott’s or Wu’s positions.

As of Tuesday, House Democrats have yet to return to Austin. Five more are needed to make quorum. Abbott is expected to call a second special session on Friday if the House does not meet quorum again.

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

WATCH: CCTV footage captures attempted murder of Pennsylvania governor

WATCH: CCTV footage captures attempted murder of Pennsylvania governor

By Christen SmithThe Center Square The Dauphin County District Attorney's Office released more than five minutes of CCTV footage that captured Cody Balmer setting fire to Gov. Josh Shapiro's official...
Most Americans say U.S. heading in the wrong direction, poll finds

Most Americans say U.S. heading in the wrong direction, poll finds

By Brett RowlandThe Center Square A new poll shows about 55% of registered voters think the U.S. is headed in the wrong direction, including 74% of Latino voters, a key...
Balmer pleads guilty to attempted murder of Pennsylvania governor

Balmer pleads guilty to attempted murder of Pennsylvania governor

By Christen SmithThe Center Square The man accused of firebombing the Pennsylvania governor’s mansion in Harrisburg pleaded guilty to attempted murder, aggravated arson and terrorism on Tuesday. Cody Balmer also...
Cook County officials warn property tax reform could hurt homeowners

Cook County officials warn property tax reform could hurt homeowners

By Catrina Barker | The Center Square contributorThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Illinois lawmakers are clashing over a Cook County property tax relief plan that restricts the types...
Maine Gov. Janet Mills officially launches U.S. Senate bid

Maine Gov. Janet Mills officially launches U.S. Senate bid

By Chris WadeThe Center Square Maine Gov. Janet Mills formally announced Tuesday that she will seek the Democratic Party's nomination to challenge incumbent Republican Sen. Susan Collins in next year's...
Illinois quick hits: Poll finds mixed reviews for Trump; posthumous medal for Kirk; transit fare increase proposed

Illinois quick hits: Poll finds mixed reviews for Trump; posthumous medal for Kirk; transit fare increase proposed

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square Poll finds mixed reviews for Trump President Donald Trump’s economic policies are getting mixed reviews from voters. The Center Square Voters'...
AARP under fire after $9 billion payment from UnitedHealthcare revealed

AARP under fire after $9 billion payment from UnitedHealthcare revealed

By Tom JoyceThe Center Square AARP is facing new scrutiny after disclosures showed it will receive $9 billion from UnitedHealthcare under a restructured deal to market AARP-branded Medicare Advantage plans....
WATCH: Trump: Pritzker should ‘beg;’ Veto Session begins as Madigan reports to prison

WATCH: Trump: Pritzker should ‘beg;’ Veto Session begins as Madigan reports to prison

By Greg Bishop | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – In today's edition of Illinois in Focus Daily, The Center Square Editor Greg Bishop shares comments from...

WATCH: Trump: Pritzker should beg for help with public safety in Chicago

By Greg Bishop | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – President Donald Trump says he doesn’t want to use the Insurrection Act to help with public safety...
L.A. congresswoman insists on health insurance tax credits

L.A. congresswoman insists on health insurance tax credits

By Dave MasonThe Center Square Democrats won’t reopen the federal government if America’s health care remains at risk, U.S. Rep. Maxine Waters, D-Los Angeles, told thousands of people at AIDS...
Newsom threatens university funding over Trump's education deal

Newsom threatens university funding over Trump’s education deal

By Esther WickhamThe Center Square California Gov. Gavin Newsom warned state universities that signing the Trump administration's education agreement would put them in direct conflict with his administration. Newsom issued...
Former Los Angeles schools chief runs against city's mayor

Former Los Angeles schools chief runs against city’s mayor

By Dave MasonThe Center Square Andrew Beutner, former superintendent of the Los Angeles Unified School District, announced Monday he’s running against Mayor Karen Bass. Beutner, 65, launched his campaign during...
Illinois quick hits: WARN report layoffs total 1,689; Powerball winners in Rochelle and Colona

Illinois quick hits: WARN report layoffs total 1,689; Powerball winners in Rochelle and Colona

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square WARN report layoffs total 1,689 According to the latest Illinois Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act (WARN) notice, 1,689 employees across...
No ethics reform in sight as ex-speaker’s scheduled prison term begins

No ethics reform in sight as ex-speaker’s scheduled prison term begins

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – As his predecessor’s scheduled 7.5-year prison term for public corruption begins, the speaker of the Illinois House...
Trump losing ground on economy, poll finds

Trump losing ground on economy, poll finds

By Brett RowlandThe Center Square Donald Trump rode a poor economy back to the White House during his 2024 campaign, but seven months into his second term, most voters aren't...