Illinois asks Supreme Court not to give Trump authority over National Guard

Spread the love

The state of Illinois asked the U.S. Supreme Court not to hear President Donald Trump’s request to deploy the National Guard to Chicago amid a disagreement about plans for immigration enforcement in the state’s most populous city.

Top attorneys for Illinois and Chicago said Trump has overstepped his authority. They were joined by officials from Los Angeles, California, and elsewhere in the legal fight over who controls the troops.

“The Court should decline applicants’ request to unsettle the equitable judgment reflected in the Seventh Circuit’s order and to take the dramatic step of permitting deployment of National Guard troops over Illinois’s objection for the handful of days the [temporary restraining order] currently remains in effect,” Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul’s legal team wrote in a legal filing.

The state and others have challenged Trump’s authority to deploy the National Guard to cities over objection of local leaders. Illinois officials said federal authorities aren’t needed.

“Applicants’ contrary arguments rest on mischaracterizations of the factual record or the lower courts’ views of the legal principles,” the state said in its response. “As the district court found, state and local law enforcement officers have handled isolated protest activities in Illinois, and there is no credible evidence to the contrary.”

America First Policy Institute, a nonprofit group, said Trump should control the orders.

“Plaintiffs have asserted nine claims, each of which is a variation on the same underlying request for the federal courts to second-guess the President’s determination that the conditions for federalizing the National Guard have been satisfied here,” attorneys for the group wrote. “There is no express private cause of action to bring these claims, and for nearly 200 years this Court has recognized that the President’s determination is nonjusticiable.”

Filings in the Illinois case came the same day that a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit overturned a temporary restraining order issued by a federal judge in Portland, Ore., removing a judicial obstruction that prevented Trump from sending Oregon National Guard troops to Portland.

The ruling comes in the wake of Trump deploying National Guard troops to U.S. cities including Los Angeles, Washington D.C., Portland, Memphis and Chicago to protect the work of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents. Agents have been attacked, hampered by agitators and protested against in U.S. cities.

The legal battle is expected to continue on multiple fronts.

While hundreds of National Guard troops are already in Illinois, U.S. District Judge April Perry stopped their deployment. She said she found federal officials’ assertions about coordinated violence by protestors “unreliable.”

Leave a Comment





Latest News Stories

Congress returns, but Trump's 'pocket rescissions' snarls govt funding process

Congress returns, but Trump’s ‘pocket rescissions’ snarls govt funding process

By Thérèse BoudreauxThe Center Square It’s Congress’ first day back in session, but President Donald Trump’s clawback of nearly $5 billion in congressionally-approved spending has alienated Democrats, whose cooperation is...
Judge rules against Trump on National Guard, Marines in California

Judge rules against Trump on National Guard, Marines in California

By Dave MasonThe Center Square A federal judge Tuesday ruled against President Donald Trump’s deployment of the California National Guard and Marines in Los Angeles. U.S. District Court Judge Charles...
Permian Basin producers reduce methane intensity by 50% as production increases

Permian Basin producers reduce methane intensity by 50% as production increases

By Bethany BlankleyThe Center Square Methane emissions intensity for upstream oil and natural gas operations in the Permian Basin declined by more than 50% in two years, according to an...
FDA pushes nicotine pouch makers to use child-resistant packaging

FDA pushes nicotine pouch makers to use child-resistant packaging

By Brett RowlandThe Center Square The Food and Drug Administration is pushing nicotine pouch manufacturers to use child-resistant packaging in response to an increase in accidental exposures among children. All...
Banning AI instruction in college could stifle innovation, IL lawmaker says

Banning AI instruction in college could stifle innovation, IL lawmaker says

By Catrina Barker | The Center Square contributorThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Supporters of a new law prohibiting artificial intelligence being the sole instructor in community college say...
WATCH: Chicago braces for federal law enforcement; Dabrowski on public safety, education

WATCH: Chicago braces for federal law enforcement; Dabrowski on public safety, education

By Greg Bishop | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – In today's edition of Illinois in Focus Daily, The Center Square Editor Greg Bishop gets to the...
Illinois quick hits: Eight dead after weekend violence; Mexican national's extradition sought

Illinois quick hits: Eight dead after weekend violence; Mexican national’s extradition sought

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square Eight dead after weekend violence Chicago Police say more than 55 people were shot, at least eight fatally, in the city...
Chinese networks use U.S. to launder billions for Mexican cartels

Chinese networks use U.S. to launder billions for Mexican cartels

By Brett RowlandThe Center Square Chinese networks are laundering billions of dollars in drug cartel cash through the U.S. financial system, according to a new report from the Treasury Department....
Alternative tax-hike ideas emerge to fund Illinois public transit

Alternative tax-hike ideas emerge to fund Illinois public transit

By Jim Talamonti | The Center SquareThe Center Square (The Center Square) – Illinois lawmakers are proposing more options to address a $770 million fiscal cliff for public transit. After...
Kamala Harris pro-union X post inspires major Labor Day backlash

Kamala Harris pro-union X post inspires major Labor Day backlash

By Carleen JohnsonThe Center Square An X post from former Vice President Kamala Harris on this Labor Day has generated hundreds of mostly critical comments. “When unions are strong, our...
Speaker Mike Johnson says Shreveport 'Democratic DA' is to blame for high crime

Speaker Mike Johnson says Shreveport ‘Democratic DA’ is to blame for high crime

By Emilee CalamettiThe Center Square When asked about crime in Caddo Parish, U.S. House Speaker Mike Johnson said the "Democratic DA" is not prosecuting as he should. Johnson appeared on...
Trump says he will sign executive order ending mail-in voting

Trump says he will sign executive order ending mail-in voting

By Elyse ApelThe Center Square President Donald Trump said he will be signing an executive order ending mail-in voting and requiring voter ID. “Voter I.D. Must Be Part of Every...
Everyday Economics: Jobs report takes center stage in week ahead

Everyday Economics: Jobs report takes center stage in week ahead

By Orphe DivounguyThe Center Square The economy finds itself in an uncomfortable position where growth is cooling while inflation pressures intensify. The Fed's preferred inflation measure (PCE) shows core inflation...
Legislator warns bad Illinois policy continues to hurt business investment

Legislator warns bad Illinois policy continues to hurt business investment

By Glenn Minnis | The Center Square contributorThe Center Square (The Center Square) – With businesses in Illinois now suffering on multiple levels, state Rep. Brad Halbrook argues it’s clear...
As summer ends, budget battles and investigations await

As summer ends, budget battles and investigations await

By Morgan SweeneyThe Center Square While Labor Day marks the unofficial end of summer for many, it’s also the final day of Congress’ August recess, with lawmakers returning to Washington...